The first page of the petition
Thursday, November 19, 2026, 20:02 As part of the recent deal for the release of hostages held by Hamas in the Gaza Strip, roughly one thousand terrorists were released from Israeli prisons, including murderers serving long sentences.
Under Section 8b(d) of the Government Law, these releases are conditional. A released terrorist can be returned to prison to serve the remainder of his original sentence if a committee—which is required by law to be established—determines that he has committed an offense punishable by at least three months’ imprisonment. The committee is to consist of a retired judge appointed by the Prime Minister, a representative of the Ministry of Justice, and a representative of either the Ministry of Defense or the Ministry of National Security, as appropriate.
However, since the committee has not been established—despite the statutory requirement—released terrorists who have reoffended have not had their cases reviewed, and have not been returned to prison. They are therefore free to resume terrorist activity without facing the consequences the law itself provides, solely because the government has failed to implement it.
After nearly two years during which the government failed to establish the required committee, Government Secretary Yossi Fuchs appeared today (Thursday) before the High Court of Justice in connection with the petition filed by Honenu. In a closed session, he explained why the government has not yet established the committee. The State Attorney’s Office requested an additional extension. The High Court has not yet issued a decision.
The petition states, among other things: “Releasing terrorists before they have completed their sentences is an exceptional arrangement forced on the State of Israel by the need to free the hostages from terrorist organizations. Their release is a prize for terrorism. … The release is conditional, and the inherent condition is that the released prisoners will not continue to commit offenses. If a released prisoner commits an offense before the end of his original sentence, he must return to prison to serve the remainder of that sentence.
“The government is not permitted to thwart the law by refusing to establish a committee that is supposed to examine the individual cases to which the law applies.”
The petition asks the Court to issue an order nisi (conditional order) requiring the respondents—the Prime Minister, the Minister of Justice, and the Minister of Defense—to explain why they will not appoint the committee, or at least discuss its appointment, as soon as possible.
Attorney Yitzhak Bam, who represents Honenu in the petition, said: “Terrorists belong in prison. It is regrettable that the Government Secretary had to appear in court to explain to the High Court justices why the government is not doing what the law requires in order to return terrorists to prison.”
